Audi S5: Years to Avoid and Why
The Audi S5, a high-performance coupe and convertible, has been a popular choice among enthusiasts since its inception in 2007. However, like any car, certain model years have been plagued by more problems than others. This article delves into the specific years to avoid when considering an S5, highlighting common issues and providing insights into why they should be avoided.
2008-2011: The Early Years and Their Growing Pains
The first generation S5 (2008-2011) marked the model’s arrival, boasting a powerful 4.2L V8 engine and sporty handling. However, these early years were not without their hiccups.
Common Problems:
- Engine Problems: The 4.2L V8, while powerful, was known for premature valve guide wear, leading to excessive oil consumption and potentially engine damage. This issue, often manifesting between 60,000-100,000 miles, could lead to costly repairs.
- Transmission Issues: The six-speed automatic transmission, particularly in the early models, was prone to shuddering, slipping, and even complete failure. While Audi addressed this issue with software updates, many owners still experienced transmission problems.
- Electrical Glitches: The S5’s complex electronics system was susceptible to glitches, including issues with the climate control, navigation system, and even the instrument cluster. These problems could range from minor annoyances to major safety concerns.
- Suspension Issues: The S5’s sport-tuned suspension, while offering excellent handling, could wear out prematurely, leading to squeaking, clunking, and uneven tire wear.
Why Avoid: The first generation S5, particularly those from 2008-2011, carry a higher risk of encountering these issues. While some owners may have experienced no problems, the potential for costly repairs and reliability concerns makes these years less desirable.
2012-2016: The Supercharged Era and its Challenges
The second generation S5 (2012-2016) saw the introduction of a supercharged 3.0L V6 engine, replacing the previous V8. This engine offered improved fuel efficiency and performance, but it also came with its own set of challenges.
Common Problems:
- Supercharger Issues: The supercharger, while boosting performance, was prone to premature wear and tear, leading to noise, loss of power, and even failure. Replacing the supercharger could be an expensive undertaking.
- Transmission Problems: The seven-speed dual-clutch S tronic transmission, while generally reliable, could experience occasional shuddering, especially during low-speed driving. Some owners also reported transmission failures, although less frequently than the previous generation.
- Electrical Glitches: The S5’s electrical system continued to be a source of issues, with reports of faulty sensors, malfunctioning lights, and even problems with the parking brake.
- Suspension Issues: The sport-tuned suspension, while providing excellent handling, remained prone to premature wear, especially on rough roads.
Why Avoid: While the second generation S5 offered improved performance and fuel economy, the supercharger issues and occasional transmission problems make these years less desirable. It’s important to thoroughly inspect any potential purchase for signs of supercharger wear and have the transmission checked for proper operation.
2017-Present: The New Generation and its Potential Pitfalls
The current generation S5 (2017-present) boasts a refined design, improved performance, and an updated interior. However, even this newer model is not immune to potential issues.
Common Problems:
- Engine Problems: While the 3.0L V6 engine is generally reliable, some owners have reported issues with the turbocharger, leading to reduced power and potential engine damage.
- Transmission Issues: The S tronic transmission, while generally reliable, has been known to exhibit occasional shuddering, especially during low-speed driving.
- Electrical Glitches: The S5’s complex electronics system, while improved, can still experience occasional glitches, including issues with the infotainment system, climate control, and even the driver assistance features.
- Suspension Issues: The sport-tuned suspension, while offering excellent handling, can still wear out prematurely, especially on rough roads.
Why Avoid: While the current generation S5 is generally considered reliable, the potential for engine and transmission issues, along with the ongoing susceptibility to electrical glitches, should be considered. Thoroughly inspecting any potential purchase and checking for any warning lights or service records is essential.
Tips for Choosing a Reliable S5:
- Thorough Inspection: Always have a pre-purchase inspection conducted by a qualified mechanic. This will help identify any potential issues that may not be immediately apparent.
- Service Records: Request the vehicle’s service records from the previous owner. This will provide insights into the car’s maintenance history and any potential problems that may have been addressed.
- Research: Before purchasing, thoroughly research the specific model year you’re interested in. Online forums and owner reviews can provide valuable insights into common issues and potential red flags.
- Extended Warranty: Consider purchasing an extended warranty, especially for older models. This can provide financial protection against unexpected repairs.
Conclusion:
While the Audi S5 offers a compelling blend of performance, luxury, and style, certain model years are more prone to issues than others. By being aware of the potential problems and following the tips outlined above, buyers can increase their chances of finding a reliable and enjoyable S5. Remember, thorough research and a comprehensive inspection are crucial steps in ensuring a positive ownership experience.
